Hidden gem games you've probably never heard of
"Hidden gem" gets overused, so we mean it strictly: mid-tier visibility, not mid-tier quality. Every game below has strong reviews and a devoted fanbase but never quite broke through to the AAA marketing budget. If you've been playing the same five franchises for years, start here.
How we picked: strong critical reception (roughly Metacritic 80-88, the same "hidden gem" band our recommendation quiz uses), a distinctive idea instead of a familiar formula, and low enough mainstream visibility that most players genuinely haven't tried them yet.
Return of the Obra Dinn
A monochrome deduction puzzle set on a doomed 19th-century ship. Unlike anything else in games.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealPentiment
Obsidian's murder mystery hand-drawn like an illuminated manuscript — dialogue-driven, historical, and quietly incredible.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealAnimal Well
A dense, secret-packed metroidvania made by one person. The kind of game the community is still decoding.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealKentucky Route Zero
A dreamlike magical-realist road trip told as five episodic acts. Slow, strange, unforgettable.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealThe Messenger
Starts as a Ninja Gaiden homage, becomes something completely different halfway through. Trust the twist.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealTunic
An adorable little fox in an isometric world with a manual you have to reconstruct. Actually a hardcore puzzle game in disguise.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealBaba Is You
A puzzle game where you rewrite the rules by pushing words around the level. Genuinely mind-bending.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealChants of Sennaar
A gorgeous puzzle game about deciphering five invented languages, one glyph at a time.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealHi-Fi Rush
A rhythm-action character-action game that came out with zero marketing and immediately became a cult favourite.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealOuter Wilds
A 22-minute solar system on a time loop. One of the most beloved games of the decade, still under-played.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealDisco Elysium
A dialogue-driven detective RPG with the best writing in games. Not obscure — just chronically underplayed.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealUnpacking
A quiet game about moving house that tells a full life story through the things you own.
Live prices
via IsThereAnyDealNot finding the right fit?
Take the 60-second quiz and we'll surface picks tuned to your vibe, session length, and platforms.
Take the quiz